The Unbearable Lightness of Being Hungry | A Sydney Food Blog

Black Star Pastry, Newtown (again)

June 21st, 2009  |  Published in Uncategorized  |  8 Comments

I know I blogged about Black Star Pastry last year but I was recently re-reminded of how great it is. The macro-sized patisserie has sort of provided the menu to my week – or a kind of diary spelt in sugar, ganache, elderflower and rosewater.

It started last Saturday with a Zucchini and Pumpkin Muffin ($3.50) I bought, just before the gavel came down on a house that Will really wanted to buy at auction. I needed some oven-baked-fortification to steel myself for the scary bout of bidding I was about to witness. I really liked the muffin (whoever knew that timid zucchini actually had flavour?) but could only eat half of it before the auction started. It was that nerve-wracking.

I’ll spare you a dramatic re-telling of the actual auction (but if you want, you can imagine a cheesy movie montage with overloud timpani and bad close-ups of people’s sweaty foreheads, etc), only to say we were hugely relieved when the auctioneer yelled ‘Sold’. Will got the house, despite last-minute deviousness by another bidder we have since dubbed ‘Snake-In-The-Grass’.

So we had a celebratory Rose and Lilac Macaron ($3.50) a few hours later. And it was occasion-worthy: crumbly when you split it, but crisp when you bit in and the filling was a liquid hit of rosewater delicious.

My bulk-Black-Star-Pastry-buying that day also included a Mandarin and Lemon Myrtle Panna Cotta ($5). I liked how the mandarin pieces were playing it both ways: gloopy-sweet and a little tart, with a few shreds of lemon myrtle for modulated punch – like the feisty topic that ignites an otherwise civil dinner party conversation.

I ate a third of it, left it in Will’s fridge and a day or so later, reminded him not to forget it.

“Too late, I yum’d that up yesterday,” he said.

Later in the week, I went on another buying blitz at Black Star Pastry. This time, the treats were for a dinner being thrown by Blake and Lex (who make the most moreish mushroom soup and za’atar bread I’ve ever eaten).

You can see (above), the Strawberry Watermelon Rose Cream Cake ($6), Elderflower Cheesecake ($6), Chocolate Hazelnut Torte ($6), Saffron Mango Shortbread ($3) and another rose-speckled macaron. All are as delicious as they look and the cheesecake is definitely a conversation-starter: particularly regarding the mysterious concentric circles trapped in the icing (our Sherlock Holmes-like guess: grapes, sliced painfully thin).

What you can’t see above is the slick chocolate topping of the torte (a casualty of cake-box transportation, the icing was wiped clean against the lid and diligently spot-removed, one spoonful at a time, by Will).

You also can’t see the Mushroom, Pine Nut, Spinach Pithivier ($5), a flaky, crusty pie-slice that completely monopolised my thoughts for a few days after I had it for lunch. The sweet, near-caramelised mushrooms still haven’t entirely left my brain and I have an auto-craving right now, just thinking about it.

I asked one staff member what it was they did to the mushrooms that made them so tasty. All she said was that they used, “lots of fresh herbs, lots of love”.

So I am plotting my next visit again (hopefully it coincides with pithivier presence on the counter). Better still, Will’s new house is within walking distance of Black Star Pastry. So I’ll have to improve my cake-box tranportation methods, because it’ll be hard to fight the gravitational path that curves towards this wonderful patisserie.

Black Star Pastry, 277 Australia St, Newtown NSW, 2042, (02) 9557 8656

Tags: , ,


  1. Spikeabell says:

    ooooooh, my tastebuds are in tormented tantalization..currently plotting a time to visit. Love your blog. -Spike.

  2. Debbie Ann says:

    We were there yesterday – I had a great tarte tatin and my partner had a fantastic cannelle – have you tried those, they are great.

    I think lots of love might mean lots of butter!!

    I love Black Star!

  3. leetranlam says:

    Thanks for the lovely comments! I have heard so much about the cannelle and really must add that to my shopping list next time I’m there.
    “Lots of butter” – that is hilarious, Debbie Ann (and probably true!)

  4. looks like some great choices. i tried the elderflower cheesecake and strawberry and watermelon cake just on the weekend. 🙂

  5. Kate says:

    Thanks for your lovely comment Lee Tran – I was just on my way over *here* to thank you for this recommendation!

    Went there yesterday and have firmly bookmarked it as a firm favourite. Many thanks – after this and the Clipper Cafe, I trust everything you say. Can’t wait to see where you go next xx

  6. leetranlam says:

    Glad you had sweet-tooth-rewarding visits Simon & Kate! And thanks especially for your kudos, Kate. Ah, the pressure … ! Hope the next recommendation lives up to your excellent, gold-star standards.

  7. Squeak has just headed there now… eclairs are a must!

  8. Kate says:

    I am of the firm belief that the watermelon rose etc. slice ACTUALLY tastes like what the colour pink would taste like 🙂 This place is heaven!

Your Comments



Hi, I'm Lee Tran Lam. When not blogging with my mouth full, I'm usually writing, presenting Local Fidelity on FBi radio, making zines, producing podcasts or continually breaking promises about how I really am gonna get through my book pile one day.

All the good pictures on this blog are by photography ace (and patient boyfriend), Will Reichelt, (all the dodgy ones can be credited to me)!

The lovely banner is by friend and ultra-talented illustrator Grace Lee.

This site redesign was made possible by the next-level generosity and expertise of Daniel Boud, whose code-tinkering ways are only outranked by his seriously inspired way with a camera.

You can read more about my co-conspirators here.

This is a blog I do for pure fun and zero influence – there's no sponsorship, sneaky advertorial or advertising. I pay for all the food mentioned, 'cos it seems the ethical thing to do.


This is a blog about eating and drinking in Sydney, Australia (with the odd cross-border or off-topic detour). BYO appetite.

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.